Madeira is an island surrounded by the Atlantic, so of course seafood is a must. Funny enough, I used to be vegetarian when I first moved here… but with fresh tuna, octopus, and the iconic espada (scabbard fish) on every menu, I slowly gave in. Now, I can’t imagine skipping the seafood when eating out. Whether it’s traditional dishes like lapas (grilled mussels) or espada with banana, or something more modern and fusion – there’s something here for every seafood lover. Here are 6 seafood restaurants in Madeira that I’ve personally tried and loved:

If you enjoy my content, you can support me with a coffee (or a Poncha) on buymeacoffee.com/your_madeira. Thank you!

Peixaria da Avenida, Funchal

Just across the street from the beautiful Parque Santa Catarina, this place doesn’t look like much from the outside — but don’t let that fool you. The seafood pasta is one of the best I’ve had anywhere, and the tuna steak is cooked just right every time. I take all my visiting friends here, and it’s also where I had my first date with my boyfriend (our relationship was clearly off to a strong start). Friendly service, fast kitchen, and fresh fish — what more could you want?

O Basalto, Funchal

Fernando’s, Funchal

Tucked away in a small side street near the main square, this little gem is easy to miss — but absolutely worth the effort. There are only a few tables inside and some more outside, so either book ahead or arrive early. While they also serve meat and pasta, the fish is where it’s at. The tuna steak I had here was perfect, and they even served a proper side salad (not just lettuce and tomato — Madeira folks will know what I mean). It feels like a cozy family-run place with genuine hospitality.

Leme Marisqueira, Calheta

If you’re in Calheta for a beach day, don’t miss this marina-side restaurant. It’s a casual spot with fresh seafood and surprisingly affordable prices. I had the scabbard fish picado in a rich tomato sauce and loved every bite. Great portion sizes too, which is always a win after swimming all day. Try to catch sunset while you’re there — the marina view is lovely.

O Ideal, Paul do Mar

Paul do Mar has a few good seafood spots, but O Ideal is my favorite. It’s relaxed, right across from the beach, and has that friendly local feel. You can build your own picado (a traditional Madeiran dish for sharing) with options like calamari, octopus, or scabbard fish. I love the laid-back vibes here — perfect after a coastal drive or a day at the beach.

Bar Praia do Laje, Seixal

This hidden gem is on Madeira’s quieter north coast, just a short drive from Seixal Beach. It’s simple, local, and delicious. They grill the fish right there next to the sea, and the limited menu means everything is freshly cooked. Fewer tourists make this feel like an authentic island escape.

If you love seafood (or even if you’re still warming up to it), Madeira is the place to dive in. The fish is fresh, the views are stunning, and there’s nothing like a sunset meal by the sea. Looking for even more recommendations? Check out my Ultimate Madeira Travel Guide, which includes local dishes to try and the best restaurants you must visit.

p.s. no matter where you decide to eat, don’t forget to have a poncha with your meal 🙂